THE FIELD GUIDE

The Good Samaritan: How to Save Vicho

To keep Vicho alive, uncover what happened at the farm, tell him the truth and offer a blood supply from the transports.

Start The Good Samaritan with Svartrau’s medic

Complete the warehouse stage of A Study in Crimson first, including the closing conversation that opens Vicho’s shop. During the next daytime period, visit the medic southeast of Altenmarkt in Svartrau City. Accept his request to take Medicaments to a secluded farm south of the city.

Schedule the farm visit for daylight if you want the optional soul conversation: Compel Soul requires Coen’s human form. This gives you time to investigate the dead before returning to the city for the nighttime confrontation.

Native Svartrau map marking the quest-giving medic and Vicho’s houseTake a closer look
The teal pin identifies the medic for this quest. The red pin distinguishes Vicho’s nearby house.
Native Svartrau map marking the quest-giving medic and Vicho’s house

The teal pin identifies the medic for this quest. The red pin distinguishes Vicho’s nearby house.

Search the farmhouse and question its dead resident

Travel south out of Svartrau to the farm in The Silts. Svartrau South shrine lies north of the farmhouse area, while St. Mihai’s Road shrine is farther west. Use those landmarks to orient yourself, then follow the delivery objective into the property.

The bodies around the farm turn the delivery into an investigation. Use Focus to pick out the remains and clues. Search behind the hut’s front door for Farmer’s Sword, and inspect the farmer to obtain Wedding Headband. These are catalysts for questioning the corpse inside the farmhouse.

Use both clues during the Compel Soul conversation; they open separate topics about the family. The account reveals that someone escaped, giving you a reason to search beyond the house. Finish this questioning before telling Vicho what happened to the farmers, because that report can close the soul conversation.

Native map showing the farmhouse investigation area south of Svartrau South shrine and east of St. Mihai’s Road shrineTake a closer look
The outlined circle marks the farmhouse search area; it does not pinpoint a body or an interior doorway.
Native map showing the farmhouse investigation area south of Svartrau South shrine and east of St. Mihai’s Road shrine

The outlined circle marks the farmhouse search area; it does not pinpoint a body or an interior doorway.

Follow the blood trail to the missing body

Follow the bloody tracks away from the farm toward the field to its south and southwest. Two wolves are standing over another corpse. Kill them before approaching, then inspect and loot the body to obtain Warning from Simeon. Read the document to uncover Vicho’s involvement in the killings.

This is a different body from the one you questioned indoors. If you have finished the soul conversation but still lack the warning, continue along the trail instead of repeating the farmhouse search. The letter is also different from Letter from Doctor Simeon, which you found on Devora during the earlier investigation.

Finding the warning reopens A Study in Crimson. The returning quest title means new evidence has changed the case; you do not need to redo the warehouse or find another copy of its key.

Investigation diagram separating the farmhouse soul and its two catalysts from the southern corpse carrying Warning from SimeonTake a closer look
Read the two columns as separate investigations. The arrows connect evidence to its use, not positions within the farm.
Investigation diagram separating the farmhouse soul and its two catalysts from the southern corpse carrying Warning from Simeon

Read the two columns as separate investigations. The arrows connect evidence to its use, not positions within the farm.

Report to the medic, then visit Vicho at night

Return to the medic during the day and explain the farmers’ fate. This completes The Good Samaritan and pays 25 denarii. That payment belongs to the delivery investigation; it is separate from resolving Vicho’s reopened quest.

After dark, return to Vicho’s house. If the street-level door is locked, use Shadowstep to reach the upstairs balcony entrance.

Do not blame bandits if you want the rescue route. That response diverts the investigation away from the truth instead of leading through the confrontation below. Save before opening the conversation if you want to compare both outcomes.

Choose these replies to keep Vicho alive

Follow this sequence from opening the conversation through the final reassurance. The first three replies reveal the accusation; the remaining eight persuade Vicho to keep living.

Choose these replies to keep Vicho alive
OrderReply
1Vicho, we need to talk.
2You don’t remember?
3I’m sorry — but I think you’re the killer, Vicho.
4What happened to you — it’s terrible.
5Don’t do it, Vicho.
6Your condition — it’s a gift.
7Help others.
8But you have me now.
9I’ll provide you with blood.
10From blood transports.
11I don’t think you’re a monster.

Collect Vicho’s Cross and compare the endings

When you convince him to live, Vicho gives you Vicho’s Cross directly. He remains available as a nighttime merchant, and you take responsibility for his future blood requests. Choose this outcome if you still want access to his shop and are willing to return when he needs help.

If the conversation instead leads to accompanying him to see the sunrise, it has entered the death branch. After that ending, return upstairs in his house and search the altar beside his bed for the cross. His death also ends access to the shop.

If you intended to save him but reached the sunrise invitation, return to a save from before the confrontation and use the dialogue sequence above.

Outcome diagram comparing a direct cross reward and continuing trade with the sunrise ending and later pickup at Vicho’s houseTake a closer look
Follow either column from the decision to the reward and merchant outcome. This is a branch diagram, not a scene from the game.
Outcome diagram comparing a direct cross reward and continuing trade with the sunrise ending and later pickup at Vicho’s house

Follow either column from the decision to the reward and merchant outcome. This is a branch diagram, not a scene from the game.

Answer the later Unquenchable Thirst requests

Saving Vicho starts the continuing blood-delivery side quest, Unquenchable Thirst. When a request appears, bring an accepted blood item to him that night, before the next morning. Use the active request to plan your return instead of assuming that obtaining the cross finishes every obligation.

Vial of Human Blood, Tainted Marrow, Murohn Blood and Kobold Blood are among the items he accepts. Blood supplies from Ambrus’s camps can help you keep a reserve. Since some of these items are also consumables for Coen, set one aside before using the rest during exploration.

Follow the Vicho side quest in your journal. Xanthe’s Blood Guards: Unquenchable Thirst is a separate court operation with a similar name and does not satisfy his request.